6 minutes
Key Survey Takeaways
As competition for executive talent continues to intensify, credit unions are placing greater emphasis on compensation and benefit programs designed to recruit, retain, and reward high-performing leaders. The findings from surveys like the Gallagher Executive Compensation and Benefits Survey for Credit Unions and CUES Compensation Survey highlight a rapidly evolving marketplace where executive compensation is rising, incentive opportunities are expanding, and nonqualified benefit plans remain a cornerstone of long-term retention strategies.
As a result, credit unions are increasingly turning to industry benchmarking and compensation data to make informed decisions that support competitive retention strategies and long-term succession planning.
The 2026 Gallagher survey, which included responses from 549 credit unions and approximately 2,000 executives nationwide, provides valuable insight into how organizations are adapting their compensation philosophies to address succession concerns, leadership shortages, and increasing competition for proven executive talent.
Complementing these findings, the 2026 CUES survey, with responses from more than 300 credit unions, offers additional perspective on compensation and governance trends across the credit union industry.
One of the most notable findings is the continued acceleration of CEO compensation. For all credit asset sizes, the Gallagher survey found that the average chief executive salary increased 9% year over year, rising from $224,600 to $244,500. This increase reflects a marketplace characterized by aggressive strategic growth initiatives, merger activity, succession planning challenges, and a growing number of executive retirements.
Credit unions are recognizing that retaining experienced leadership often costs less than replacing it, especially in a highly competitive recruiting environment.
Looking specifically at credit unions with $1 billion to $3 billion in assets, both surveys tell a similar story regarding the market value of executive leadership. The Gallagher survey found for credit unions in this asset range, median salary was $648,000 (up from $603,230 in 2025). Similarly, the CUES Survey found median salary for credit unions $1B-$3B in assets was $643,194.
Variable compensation also continues to play a significant role in executive rewards programs. Findings from both the Gallagher and CUES surveys point to a similar trend, with target incentive opportunities representing a meaningful portion of executive compensation.
Gallagher reported an average CEO target bonus of 14% of salary, while the CUES survey found an overall target of 18% across credit unions. In both surveys, incentive opportunities generally increase with asset size, reflecting a stronger emphasis on aligning executive rewards with organizational performance and strategic objectives. This trend reinforces the growing importance of pay-for-performance structures within executive compensation programs.
<NON QUALIFIED BENEFIT PLAN graphic here>
Source: 2026 Gallagher Executive Compensation and Benefits Survey for Credit Unions
Beyond salary and bonuses, nonqualified executive benefit plans remain one of the most widely utilized retention tools in the industry. The Gallagher survey found among credit unions with more than $250 million in assets, 87% provide a nonqualified benefit plan to executives, while 32% extend these benefits to other leaders and managers. As asset size increases, adoption rates among both executive and management groups continue to climb.
These plans, which may include split dollar arrangements, 457(f) plans, 457(b) plans, incentive programs, bonus plans, and death-benefit-only plans, help bridge retirement income gaps that traditional retirement plans often cannot fully address for highly compensated employees. Because nonqualified plans can be tailored to individual executives and organizational objectives, they continue to be viewed as widely used tools for retention, leadership continuity, and succession planning.
<CEO SPLIT vs 457f graphic here>
Source: 2026 Gallagher Executive Compensation and Benefits Survey for Credit Unions
Among all nonqualified benefit strategies, split dollar plans continue to gain traction. Findings from both the Gallagher and CUES surveys tell a similar story, showing that roughly one-quarter of credit unions offer a split dollar plan to their CEO (25% and 21%, respectively). This alignment reinforces the growing recognition of split dollar programs as a cost-effective tool for retaining key executives while supporting long-term organizational goals.
Split dollar plans are particularly attractive because they provide tax-free retirement income to participants while allowing the credit union to recover its original investment, plus interest, at the conclusion of the arrangement. For plans based on pre-retirement salary, the Gallagher survey found the average target benefit equals approximately 63% of salary, highlighting the substantial retirement income replacement these programs can provide.
Both surveys also point to an important demographic trend that credit union boards cannot afford to ignore. The CUES survey found that the average age of credit union CEOs is 57 years old, while the Gallagher survey revealed that 29% of CEOs are age 60 or older and 53% are age 55 or older. Together, these findings highlight the growing importance of retirement readiness and succession planning, as a significant portion of industry leadership may be approaching retirement within the coming decade.
As a result, succession planning is moving from a future consideration to an immediate priority for many organizations. Credit unions facing potential leadership transitions must evaluate not only their recruiting strategies but also the compensation and benefit programs needed to retain emerging leaders and maintain continuity during periods of change. Competitive executive benefit offerings can play a critical role in reducing turnover risk and preserving institutional knowledge.
The survey findings reveal an industry that continues to prioritize leadership by investing in competitive compensation and benefits programs designed to attract, retain, and reward top talent. Rising salaries, expanding incentive opportunities, growing adoption of nonqualified benefit plans, and increased focus on succession planning all underscore the value credit unions place on executive talent.
Organizations that regularly benchmark their compensation and benefits against peers better position themselves to make informed decisions, remain competitive in the talent market, and support long-term strategic objectives. As executive recruiting and retention challenges persist, the survey findings reinforce the importance of a proactive compensation and benefits strategy.
Credit unions that remain attentive to market trends and invest in their leadership teams are setting themselves up for sustained success in an evolving industry.
If you would like a copy of Gallagher’s full survey results, please contact Bryn_Post@ajg.com. You can find more information on the CUES survey here.
Bryn Post, Client Marketing Director for Gallagher’s Executive Benefits for Credit Unions team, brings more than 20 years of experience across a variety of marketing roles and eight years focused specifically on serving the credit union industry. She partners closely with Gallagher’s consultants to develop resources and data-driven content to help credit union boards and executives navigate compensation, retention, and leadership challenges. Bryn plays a key role in managing Gallagher’s annual survey, a complimentary resource provided to the credit union industry and one of the more widely utilized benchmarking studies available to the industry. She graduated from Clemson University with a bachelor’s degree in marketing.
Consulting and insurance brokerage services to be provided by Gallagher Benefit Services, Inc. and/or its affiliate Gallagher Benefit Services (Canada) Group Inc. Gallagher Benefit Services, Inc., a non-investment firm and subsidiary of Arthur J. Gallagher & Co., is a licensed insurance agency that does business in California as “Gallagher Benefit Services of California Insurance Services” and in Massachusetts as “Gallagher Benefit Insurance Services.” GFA CD (5914139) Exp (09102028)



